EnRedados11N

External channel review — tagging rule and outcome

English · Español · Català

This page covers the first study, 14 September to 5 October 2026. The mobilisation continued: see the follow-up, from 6 October to the 11 November strike.

First study, review run on 2026-10-05. Per-channel evidence and decisions: evidence per channel (CSV).

What was reviewed

The 133 nodes that appeared in the forward and link graphs outside the sample (“external”): channels and groups that channels of the sample forwarded from, @-mentioned or linked to between 2026-09-14 and 2026-10-05.

Not reviewed: the 5 user accounts seen in groups, the 3 hidden-name forward origins, and the 35 @-handles that could not be matched to a Telegram account.

Evidence

For each external channel, its own posts since 2026-09-14 were read (forwarded messages excluded, up to 1,000 messages per channel; none reached the cap). Two counts were taken by keyword:

The first matching post is kept as evidence. Single hits were read to confirm they are about the camps; one false positive (a poem) was discarded.

Rule

  1. Engagement test. A channel is added to the sample only if it has at least one own post about the camps or the Maricarmen eviction in the window. Being forwarded by a channel in the sample is not enough: one ally channel alone (Red TEJAR) accounts for 44% of all forwards.
  2. Tag by kind of channel, for those that pass the test:
    • housing — housing organisations (tenant unions, PAH, housing assemblies).
    • ally — organisations and collectives that are not housing organisations: parties, unions, social centres, movement agendas, solidarity and anti-repression groups.
    • ally — personal channels of individuals, under the same test as organisations. Users posting inside groups are not considered.
    • media — news outlets, magazines, publishers and programmes, including party-linked ones.
  3. Aggregators and chats are decided by reading their messages, not by kind: ally if the channel speaks as a movement actor (issues or relays calls to action, publishes collectives’ statements); not added if it only reposts headlines or is open chatter among participants.
  4. Not added: channels with no camp post, noise, and channels that are private or have no public username (they cannot be read).

Outcome

Decision Channels
Added as housing 1 (PAH-VKS)
Added as ally — organisations 28
Added as ally — individuals 8
Added as ally — aggregator 1 (Malditaultraderecha)
Added as media 23
Not added — no camp post 60 (42 organisations or other, 12 media, 5 individuals, 1 group)
Not added — aggregator / chat 2 (Malditaultraderecha chat, Revolución Comunista)
Not added — unreadable 7
Not reviewed — users and hidden names 8

Four channels already in the sample as ally were retagged media so the rule is applied uniformly: Kaosenlared, L’Accent, El Faradio, Multicanal Radio.

Two channels tagged out of scope before the media category existed were then retagged media: Nuestra España Noticias (a general news outlet that covered the camps) and Geoestrategia y Política (a one-person commentary channel; its camp posts are supportive commentary rather than calls to action, so media rather than ally).

Sample after the review: 132 channels — 22 housing, 79 ally, 29 media, 2 out of scope (Roto2bot, a forum-thread bot, and MEME_CCC, a meme channel).

Decisions that needed judgement

Limits

Second round (2026-10-05)

Scanning the channels added in the first round brought 85 new channels into the graph. All 85 were reviewed with the same evidence and rule; rows are marked round 2 in the log.

Decision Channels
Added as housing 2 (Acampada per l’habitatge, the Barcelona camp’s channel; Sindicat Llogateres Mallorca)
Added as ally — organisations 9
Added as ally — aggregators 3
Added as media 21
Not added — no camp post 46 (38 organisations or other, 8 media)
Not added — aggregators 2
Not added — unreadable 2

Sample after the second round: 167 channels — 24 housing, 91 ally, 50 media, 2 out of scope.

Decisions that needed judgement:

The network now carries each reviewed channel’s category and review decision, so channels that were reviewed and not added are still labelled.

The review has not been repeated on the nodes brought in by scanning the second-round additions.

Cite this page.

DataPolitik (Heurística). External channel review — tagging rule and outcome. In Housing camps and Telegram communication networks in Spain, autumn 2026. Observation period: 14 September – 5 October 2026. Published 6 October 2026. https://datapolitik.github.io/acampadas-vivienda-report/external_review.html

Original text and figures: CC BY 4.0 · Use and citation


DataPolitikHeurística

A DataPolitik study by Heurística. · Home · Follow-up overview